Claims: Telephone Numbers

Below you’ll find a list of claim hotlines from our insurance providers.  If you have questions or need more information, please feel free to contact us.

Company Phone Number 24/7
1st Choice Auto 1-888-717-8090
Aegis 1-800-233-2160
American Modern 1-800-375-2075
Atlantic States/Donegal 1-800-877-9006
CNA Surety 1-800-331-6053
Conemaugh Valley Mutual 814-266-8737
Between 9am – 5pm. After 5 call
Castle Claims direct
@ 412-343-3223
Countryway 1-800-828-6862
(Between 8:00 am & 4:30 pm)
1-888-223-3649
(After 4:30 pm)
Dairyland (Auto) 1-800-334-0090
Dairyland (Motorcycle) 1-800-325-9559
Donegal/Atlantic States 1-800-877-9006
Donegal Glass Windshield Claims 1-866-439-4527
Everett Cash Mutual 1-888-717-8090
Fair Plan 1-800-462-4972
Farmers Mutual 1-800-545-7806
Foremost Insurance 1-800-527-3907
Infinity/Classic Collectors 1-800-252-5233
National General (formerly GMAC) 1-800-468-3466
Millville Mutual 1-800-262-8495
After hours press option 5
Motorists Mutual 1-800-876-8766
Northland 1-800-328-5972
National Flood 1-800-759-8656
Patrons Call Farmers Mutual
1-800-545-7806
Pennsylvania Workers Comp. 570-963-4621
Progressive 1-800-776-4737
Rockwood Insurance 1-800-442-8063
Travelers 1-800-252-4633
Volunteer Fire Departments 1-800-233-1957

Looking For
Buff Insurance?

Effective August 9, 2012, Buff Insurance Agency was purchased by former Buff agent Joel Straub, forming Straub Insurance, Inc.

Straub Insurance, Inc.

15957 Conneaut Lake Rd., Suite 9
Meadville, PA 16335

Phone: 814-724-2340
Toll Free: 800-571-2833
Hours: Mon — Fri 9:00 - 5:00

Privacy

Straub Insurance is committed to keeping your personal information secure. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.