Claims: Telephone Numbers
Below you’ll find a list of claim hotlines from our insurance providers. If you have questions or need more information, please feel free to contact us.
| Company | Phone Number | 24/7 |
|---|---|---|
| 1st Choice Auto | 1-888-717-8090 | |
| Aegis | 1-800-233-2160 | |
| American Modern | 1-800-375-2075 | |
| Atlantic States/Donegal | 1-800-877-9006 | |
| CNA Surety | 1-800-331-6053 | |
| Conemaugh Valley Mutual | 814-266-8737 Between 9am – 5pm. After 5 call Castle Claims direct @ 412-343-3223 |
|
| Countryway | 1-800-828-6862 (Between 8:00 am & 4:30 pm) 1-888-223-3649 (After 4:30 pm) |
|
| Dairyland (Auto) | 1-800-334-0090 | |
| Dairyland (Motorcycle) | 1-800-325-9559 | |
| Donegal/Atlantic States | 1-800-877-9006 | |
| Donegal Glass Windshield Claims | 1-866-439-4527 | |
| Everett Cash Mutual | 1-888-717-8090 | |
| Fair Plan | 1-800-462-4972 | |
| Farmers Mutual | 1-800-545-7806 | |
| Foremost Insurance | 1-800-527-3907 | |
| Infinity/Classic Collectors | 1-800-252-5233 | |
| National General (formerly GMAC) | 1-800-468-3466 | |
| Millville Mutual | 1-800-262-8495 After hours press option 5 |
|
| Motorists Mutual | 1-800-876-8766 | |
| Northland | 1-800-328-5972 | |
| National Flood | 1-800-759-8656 | |
| Patrons | Call Farmers Mutual 1-800-545-7806 |
|
| Pennsylvania Workers Comp. | 570-963-4621 | |
| Progressive | 1-800-776-4737 | |
| Rockwood Insurance | 1-800-442-8063 | |
| Travelers | 1-800-252-4633 | |
| Volunteer Fire Departments | 1-800-233-1957 |